BALTIMORE (OSV News) -- Access to sacraments for people detained by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement and concerns posed by state laws legalizing physician-assisted suicide are among the key religious liberty concerns facing the U.S. Church, bishops told OSV News in interviews at the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops' fall plenary assembly in Baltimore, held Nov. 16-19.
Archbishop Alexander K. Sample of Portland, Oregon, chairman of USCCB's Committee for Religious Liberty, told OSV News, "We're very concerned about making sure that those that are in the detention centers do have access to pastoral care in the sacraments," adding that "there's nothing inconsistent" with that right and with "lawful law enforcement."
"The church has always had a ministry to those who were incarcerated," he said. "This is a little bit of a different reality," he added.
In some cases, he said, "these are our own parishioners."
"These are members of our parishes, members of our community of faith who have been snatched right out of our midst and placed in these detention centers," he said.
The Archdiocese of St. Louis recently filed a lawsuit against the federal government over a policy it said prohibits priests from distributing Communion to and hearing confessions of ICE detainees. Bishop Brendan J. Cahill of Joliet, Illinois, chair of the USCCB’s Committee on Migration, also identified the ability to provide pastoral care to those in ICE detention as a key concern.
Not only is it crucial to be able to provide sacraments to those in detention, Bishop Cahill said in an interview with OSV News, but visiting the imprisoned is one of the seven corporal works of mercy in the Catholic Church.
"We have a right to practice our religion" by conducting the ministry, he said.
Multiple bishops also expressed concerns about state laws legalizing physician-assisted suicide.
Lawsuits filed in both Illinois and New York by Catholic organizations, spearheaded by Catholic nuns, challenge each law. The organizations argued that under the laws, their healthcare ministries could be required to facilitate such deaths for their patients in violation of their faith.
Currently in Illinois, a federal judge has temporarily blocked the state from forcing Catholic entities that challenged the law to aid terminally ill adults in dying by suicide, but their effort to make the block permanent continues.
Archbishop Ronald A. Hicks of New York recently joined four orders of nuns and other ministries in a lawsuit, filed in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of New York in Albany, challenging the state’s Medical Aid in Dying Act, which took effect Aug. 5.
A federal judge in New York has issued a temporary restraining order prohibiting that state from enforcing its law against the Catholic plaintiffs in the lawsuit while it proceeds.
"If you have a group of religious sisters who are committed to the compassionate care of people, especially when they're coming to the end of their life, and then they're being forced to have these people consider suicide as an option for ending their life, for us as Catholics, but I think also as a society, that shouldn't only be unconscionable. It's unconstitutional," Archbishop Hicks told OSV News in an interview.
It is a common misconception, he said, that "people just think this was another option, that if someone is dying, to give them the option of not suffering, and on the surface that might be something that seems desirable," but that has led to a host of negative consequences in other places that have adopted the practice, such as Canada.
In 2024, about 16,500 people died by physician-assisted suicide, according to the Canadian government's most recent data, accounting for about 5% of the country’s total deaths that year.
"It has real life consequences that we just don't want to participate in nor be forced to do so," Archbishop Hicks said.
Asked about how both efforts were driven by Catholic nuns, Archbishop HIcks called them "a great gift in our Church."
"They stand up as a witness against a culture of death, and say, at the core of who we are is Jesus, is God, who is the creator of life, who is the giver of life, and we are here to respect, honor, and to share that great dignity as a true mission," he said.
Oregon, Archbishop Sample noted, was the first U.S. state to legalize the practice of physician-assisted suicide, arguing it has had "a corrosive effect" in the more than three decades since.
"It isn't just it isn't just a matter of those who avail themselves of suicide through the assistance of physicians," he said. "It's the broader effect that that has had, and a chilling effect, really, on the culture, just the very sacredness of life, the dignity of human life, especially for the elderly."
More generally, Archbishop Hicks said, "when it comes to immigration or when it comes to right to life or assisted suicide, there are people in the world who say to the church, 'Keep your voice inside of your churches, and if you just want to talk about it locally, do that, but don't share it with the world.'"
"My point of view is that as a church, we are part of this world, and we should be able to express our values in our teachings, and to share them, and by doing that, hopefully contribute to the common good of all of society," he said.
Archbishop Sample also raised concerns about politically or religiously motivated violence, pointing to "a recent uptick" in antisemitism in the U.S., saying the bishops would continue to speak up "very strongly in defense of our brothers and sisters in the Jewish community."
He stressed in his interview that the U.S. bishops are concerned about protecting religious liberty not only for Catholics, but for other religious traditions as well.
"When religious liberty for one group is threatened, it is threatened for all of us," he said.

